3/22/2004: QUESTIONS REMAIN AS CAUSES
OF FAILED SLBM LAUNCHES IDENTIFIED Izvestiya reported on 22 March 2004 that an intergovernmental
commission formed to investigate the failed
launch of three SLBMs during the
Security 2004 command and staff
training exercise concluded that mechanical, rather than human, error was at
fault.[1] The commission, headed by the deputy head of the
General Staff
Colonel General Aleksandr Rukshin, was formed by a joint decision of the
Ministry of Defense,
the Shipbuilding Agency, and the
Aerospace Agency
on
direct orders from President Putin.
It was tasked with examining the
reasons for the failed launches from the Delfin-class [NATO Name Delta-IV]
ballistic missile submarines Novomoskovsk and
Kareliya on 17-18 February 2004.[2] Regarding the Novomoskovsk, the
commission determined that a malfunction in the ADK-3M Shlyuz portion of the
Tobol-M navigation system triggered a chain reaction that prevented the SSBN
from launching its RSM-54 [NATO designation SS-N-23 'Skiff'] Sineva SLBM
at the designated target in the Kura testing ground on the Kamchatka Peninsula.
The commission also concluded that the failed launch from the Kareliya,
in which the SLBM self-destructed less than two minutes into flight, evidently
resulted from a glitch in the command system developed by
NPO
Avtomatiki in Yekaterinburg.[1,2] However,
Commander-in-Chief of the
Navy Admiral Vladimir Kuroyedov later announced that the Kareliya
mishap stemmed from the use of a SLBM that had exceeded its recommended service
life by almost 10 years.[3] An article in Moskovskiy komsomolets
confirmed
that the SLBM launched from the Kareliya was produced in 1987, but it
also alleged that it came from a batch of missiles that the military knew to be defective. Given that the
individual SLBM also reportedly had a spotty service record, the article questioned the
possible motives for using this particular missile, especially in the wake of the failed launches
from the Novomoskovsk the preceding day.[4] This and other press reports
also suggested
that human error played a role in the failed launches.[4,5,6,7] In particular, two
officers on the Novomoskovsk who were responsible for entering targeting
data into the SLBM reportedly admitted that they either inputted the wrong
coordinates into the missile or neglected to notice that the computer system had
corrupted the data.[4] Admiral Kuroyedov, however, steadfastly refused to
acknowledge the possibility that human error at least contributed to the
circumstances that led to the failed launches.[4,5] However, on 17 March 2004 the
Novomoskovsk launched two
Sineva SLBMs from its position in the Barents Sea. The test,
witnessed personally by Admiral Kuroyedov, took place at the express request of
President Putin who wished to confirm that the Navy had addressed the causes for
the failed launches during the Security 2004 exercise. The 17 March launch ultimately proved successful, although it occurred after an unexplained four-hour delay
that once again raised speculation about the state of the naval leg of the
strategic nuclear triad.[4,8,9] Sources:
[1] Dmitriy Litovkin, "Moryaki-severomortsy zagladili konfuz," Izvestiya
online edition,
http://izvestia.ru/army/article45570,
22 March 2004.
[2] Ivan Safronov, "Genshtab vypolnil nepoletnoye zadaniye," Kommersant,
No. 042, 10 March 2004; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
[3] Aleksandr Konovalov, "Veroyatnost uspeshnykh puskov morskikh
strategicheskikh raket RSM-54 sostavlyayet tolko 95 protsentov, schitayet Glavkom
VMF RF," ITAR-TASS, 23 March 2004; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
[4] Olga Bozhyeva, "Oshibka na oshibke," Moskovskiy komsomolets, No. 23525, 19
March 2004; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
[5] "Za dvukh bitykh," Grani.Ru, 16 March 2004; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
[6] Viktor Semenov, "Perestrelka," Russkiy kuryer, No. 55, 18 March 2004; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
[7] Aleksandr Babakin, Igor Plugatarev, "'Perestrel' za 2,000,000,000 rubley,"
Nezavisimaya gazeta online edition,
http://ng.ru/politics/2004-03-03/1_army.html, 3 March 2004.
[8] "Golovnyye chasti rakety 'Sineva', zapushchennoy s atomnoy podlodki 'Novomoskovsk',
uspeshno porazili tseli na poligone," ITAR-TASS, 17 March 2004; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
[9] Ivan Safronov, "Severnyy flot proshel pereekzamenovku," Kommersant,
No. 048, 18 March 2004; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
{Entered 4/26/2004 EMC} 2/17/2004: FAILED SLBM LAUNCHES DURING SECURITY-2004 EXERCISES During the Security 2004 command and staff training exercises held from
late January to 17 February 2004, Russian forces were scheduled to launch
several SLBMs. President Putin observed the attempted launches from the
Akula-class [NATO name 'Typhoon] SSBN Arkhangelsk. The Delfin-class [NATO
Name Delta-IV] SSBN Novomoskovsk was supposed to launch an SS-N-23
(RSM-54 or RM-29RMU) SLBM toward the Kura test range in Kamchatka. Two attempted
launches from the Novomoskovsk failed, as did a launch the day
after the official end of the Security 2004 exercises from the Kareliya.
Immediately following the first failure, a flurry of reports made
contradictory claims: there was an explosion, the missile fell into the water,
the launch was blocked by a satellite, etc.
Commander-in-Chief
of the Navy Admiral Vladimir Kuroyedov quickly declared that no "physical"
launch should have taken place at all: the launch was supposed to be a
simulation.[1] Not a single commentator believed that announcement, however. It
eventually became clear that between the third and fourth minutes of the launch
sequence the targeting system of the submarine failed and the electronic system
blocked the launch.[2,3] Apparently Capt. Sergey Radchuk, the commanding officer
of the Novomoskovsk, attempted to launch a second SLBM, but also without
success. The sequence of events is somewhat murky as originally only one SLBM
launch had been announced, but subsequently all news media reported the failure
of two SLBM launches from that submarine. Some reports suggested that the second
missile failed to completely exit the tube and became stuck.[4]
The day after the Novomoskovsk's failed launches, another submarine of
the same class, Kareliya, made a fresh attempt to launch an SLBM of the
same type. At first, the flight was normal, but after 98 seconds (at the time of
the separation of the first stage) the missile began to deviate from its
trajectory, which immediately activated the self-destruction mechanism.[5,6]
This launch was attempted after Putin had already left the Northern Fleet and
flew to the Plesetsk test range to watch the launch of land-based missiles.
Four commissions were established to investigate the accidents -- one for
each submarine, one at the Makeyev design
bureau where the SS-N-23 SLBM was developed, and one at the
Krasnoyarsk Machine-Building Plant where
the missiles were produced.[6] Sources in the navy blamed faulty missiles while
representatives of the production plant declared that it was too early to
speculate.[6] First Deputy Chief of
the General Staff Colonel
General Yuriy Baluyevskiy, at a press conference at the end of the exercises,
announced that there had been no decision to withdraw the SS-N-23s from service
and said that these missiles are considered among "the most reliable." Out of 36
launches in the 1990s this was only the second failure.[7,8]
The exact circumstances of the failure are still unclear in spite of dozens
of reports. Only the second failed launch, from Kareliya, can be
confidently attributed to the missile. According to one report, that missile was
still under warranty.[9] The failure of the Novomoskovsk launches,
judging from conflicting descriptions, could be attributed to the submarine, the
missiles, or both. One unconfirmed report attributed the failed launch to a
mistake by the crew (the majority of reports, however, emphasized that the crew
made no mistakes) and to inadequate repairs at the shipyard in 2003.[9] It is
even unclear which missiles were launched: the general assumption has been
that these were RS-54s, which entered service in the mid-1980s. Their service
lives have already expired, but were extended, as is the standard practice now
in Russia. There is at least one report, however, that the failed missiles were
the 1999 modification of the SS-N-23 called Sineva.[3] The new version
carries 10 warheads instead of four and has a new navigational system.
For more information on Security-2004, see
"Military Exercises In Russia: Naval Deterrence Failures Compensated By
Strategic Rocket Success,"
http://cns.miis.edu/pubs/week/040224.htm. Sources:
[1] "Glavkom VMF: Stsenarii uchenii predusmatrival tolko uslovnyy pusk raket,"
Strana.Ru, http://www.strana.ru,
17 February 2004.
[2] Dmitriy Litovkin, "Ballisticheskiye rakety Putina ne porazili," Izvestiya,
18 February 2004.
[3] Vadim Solovev, Vladimir Ivanov, Viktor Myasnikov, "Ne v raketakh delo, a v
umnoy nachinke," Nezavisimoye voennoye obozreniye, 20 February 2004.
[4] "Vladimiru Putinu pustili 'Sinevu' v glaza," Kommersant-Daily, 18
February 2004.
[5] Vladimir Mukhin, Andrey Riskin, "Morskoy shchit Rossii vzorvalsya nad
Severnym morem," Nezavisimaya gazeta, 19 February 2004.
[6] "Rossiiskii yadernyy shchit dal treshchinu," Kommersant-Daily, 19
February 2004.
[7] "Prikazov o priostanovke ekspluatatsii samolikvidirovavsheysya rakety RS-54
ne bylo," Strana.Ru,
http://www.strana.ru, 19 February 2004.
[8] Nail Gafutulin, Sergey Severinov, Aleksandr Bogatyrev, "Proryv k oruzhiyu
novogo pokoleniya," Krasnaya zvezda, 20 February 2004.
[9] Yuliya Kalinina, Olga Bozhiyeva, "Sho to bylo?" Moskovskiy komsomolets,
20 February 2004. {Entered 3/17/04 CC}
9/2/2003: SUCCESSFUL SLBM TEST
BY
PACIFIC FLEET
On 2 September 2003, the Pacific Fleet
Kalmar-class [NATO name 'Delta III'] SSBN
Podolsk conducteda successful SLBM launch. The Russian Navy fired a R-29R [NATO designation SS-N-18 'Stingray']
missile from the Sea of Okhotsk. The warhead is reported to have
struck successfully the designated target at the Chizha testing range on the White
Sea coast, 6,000km from the launch point. [David C. Isby,
"Russian Navy tests SLBM," Jane’s Missiles and Rockets online
edition, http://jmr.janes.com, 1 November 2003]. {Entered 11/21/2003 TS}
10/12/2002: SLBMs LAUNCHED
AS PART OF LARGE TRAINING EXERCISE On 12 October 2002, Pacific and Northern Fleet ballistic missile submarines (SSBNs) participated
in a large-scale training exercise designed to test the combat readiness of the
Russian strategic nuclear forces. As part of the exercise, a Pacific Fleet SSBN in the Sea of
Okhotsk launched a sea-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) at a testing
ground target on Cape Kanin Nos on the
White Sea coast. A SLBM fired from a Northern Fleet Kalmar-class [NATO
name 'Delta III'] SSBN in the Barents Sea targeted the Kura testing ground on the Kamchatka
Peninsula.[1] According to military sources, both warheads accurately struck the
identified targets within the programmed timeframe.[1,2]
Sources:
[1] Vladimir Levin, "Yadernyye rakety proleteli nad Moskvoy," Press Center.Ru,
15 October 2002; in
Integrum
Techno, http://www.integrum.com.
[2] "V Rossii v odin den osushchestvleny puski ballisticheskikh raket
nazemnogo, morskogo i vozdushnogo bazirovaniya," Interfax, 12 October
2002. {Entered
11/15/2002 EMC}
7/12/2002: SSBN LAUNCHES
CONVERTED SLBM
On 12 July 2002, the Russian Project 667BDR Kalmar [NATO name 'Delta III']
ballistic missile submarine Ryazan launched a Volna space launch vehicle
from the Barents sea. The Volna is a converted R-29R [NATO designation SS-N-18
'Stingray'] SLBM, designed by the Makeyev
Space Missile Center. Instead of a warhead, the missile's payload was a
150kg Demonstrator-2 reentry and space descent test vehicle. This was the fourth
launch of a converted SLBM from a Russian SSBN. [Sergey Ishchenko, "Strategic Peace-loving Demonstration,"
Trud, 13 July 2002; in "Russia: Demonstrator-2 Space Vehicle Successfully
Launched From Russian Submarine 'Ryazan'," FBIS Document CEP2002071200365.]
{Entered 8/26/2002 MJ}
9/27/2001: RUSSIA TESTS SLBMS On 27 September 2001, the Northern
Fleet Akula-class [NATO name 'Typhoon'] SSBN Severstal,
commanded by Captain Aleksander Bogachev, conducted an SLBM launch. The ship
fired two missiles at the Kura target range in Kamchatka. The Severstal
returned to port at
Nerpichya on 13 November 2001.
["Raketnyy
podvodnyy kreyser 'Severstal' vernulsya na bazu Severnogo flota," Agentsvo
Voennykh Novostey, 13 November 2001; in Universal Database of Military
and Security Periodicals, http://www.eastview.com.]
{Entered on 7/22/2002 TM}
9/18/2001: RUSSIA SUCCESSFULLY TESTS SLBM On 18 September 2001, the Pacific Fleet SSBN Podolsk, commanded
by Captain Oleg Slugin, successfully carried out an SLBM launch from the Sea of
Okhotsk. Russian Navy Press Service Chief Captain Igor Dygalo
reported that the warhead struck the designated impact area at the Chizha
testing range on the coast of the Barents Sea. The test was conducted
to verify missile reliability.
["Atomnaya podlodka Tikhookeanskogo
flota proizvela uspeshnyy pusk ballisticheskoy rakety," Agentstvo
voyennykh novostey, 18 September 2001.] {Entered 10/5/2001
IA}
7/20/2001: RUSSIAN SSBN LAUNCHES
SCIENTIFIC SATELLITE On 20 July 2001 the Project 667BDR [NATO
name 'Delta III'] ballistic missile submarine Borisoglebsk launched a
Kosmos-1 scientific satellite incorporating a solar sail. The satellite was
launched using a Volna SLV, developed on the basis of the R-29R [NATO
designation SS-N-18 'Stingray'] SLBM.[1,2] In 2000 two
satellites were launched by the Project 667BDRM [NATO name 'Delta IV']
submarine Novomoskovsk, which used Shtil SLVs based on the R-29RM
SLBM [NATO designation SS-N-23 'Skiff'].[2]
Sources: [1] "Zavershena ustanovka konversionnoy rakety 'Volna' na APL 'Borisoglebsk'
dlya yeye vyvedeniya v kosmos 20 iyulya," ITAR-TASS, 17 July 2001; in
Integrum Techno, http://www.integrum.ru.
[2] Mikhail Khodarenok, "'Solnechnyy parus', kazhetsya, sgorel," Nezavisimaya
gazeta, 21 July 2001; in Integrum Techno, http://www.integrum.ru.
{Entered 8/28/2001 MJ}
2/16/2001: NORTHERN FLEET
SLBM LAUNCH An unnamed Russian ballistic missile submarine
launched an unspecified SLBM from the Barents Sea on 16 February 2001, during
the General Staff's strategic command and
staff exercise held from 13-16 February 2001. The missile struck the Kura
testing ground in Kamchatka.[1,2] Sources: [1] "Atomnyy podvodnyy raketonosets Severnogo flota proizvel uspeshnyy
pusk ballisticheskoy rakety," Interfax, 16 February 2001. [2] Vladimir Gundarov, "Popali v 'kolyshek'," Krasnaya zvezda,
17 February 2001; in Integrum Techno, http://www.integrum.ru/.
{Entered 3/20/2001 MJ}
12/27/2000: RUSSIAN SUBMARINE LAUNCHES SLBM On 27 December 2000, the Russian SSBN Novomoskovsk (CNS believes it
is the K-407, a Delfin class [NATO name 'Delta IV'] nuclear submarine)
launched a ballistic missile from the Barents Sea. According to Russian Navy
spokesperson Igor Dygalo, the missile's warhead hit the designated impact area
at the Kura testing range on the Kamchatka Peninsula. The launch was conducted
to check the preparedness of the Russian strategic naval forces. ["Segodnya s podvodnogo raketonostsa 'Novomoskovsk' iz
akvatorii Barentseva morya proizveden zapusk ballisticheskoy rakety,"
RosBiznesKkonsalting, 27 December 2000; in UNIAN, 25-31 December 2000, no.
52.] {Entered 10/1/2001 EF} 9/12/2000: NORTHERN FLEET SLBM LAUNCHED
FROM SSBN IN WAKE OF KURSK ACCIDENT According to Krasnaya zvezda, on 10
September 2000 one RSM-54 ballistic missile [NATO designation SS-N-23 'Skiff'] was launched from the Russian Northern Fleet
Delta-IV class SSBN Kareliya in the Barents
Sea and successfully hit its target at the Kura test range near
Kamchatka.[1] Present at the launch were Commander of the
Russian Navy Vladimir Kuroyedov, Northern Fleet Commander Admiral
Vyacheslav Popov, and Murmansk Oblast Governor Yuriy Yevdokimov.
Northern Fleet spokesman Vladimir Navrotsky stated that the test launch was part
of the Northen Fleet's training program.[2] Krasnaya zvezda reporters
speculated that the launch was intended to make a political statement to
reassure the public that Russia is still militarily strong in the wake of
the Kursk accident.[1]
Sources: [1] Andrey Gavrilenko & Vladimir
Gundarov, "Vysokiye orbity rossiyskogo flota: Uspeshnym puskom
ballisticheskoy rakety podvodniki podtverdili nadezhnost yadernogo shchita
Rossii," Krasnay zvezda, 14 September 2000, p. 1; in WPS Oborona i
bezopasnost,
No. 109, 18 September 2000. [2]" Ballistic Missile Launched From
Northern Fleet Submarine," Interfax, No. 3, 12 September 2000. {Entered 9/20/2000 RG} 3/27/2000: NORTHERN FLEET SLBM TEST LAUNCH SUCCESSFUL On Monday 27 March 2000 two RSM-54 ballistic missiles
(NATO designation SS-N-23 'Skiff' ) were launched at 10 a.m. (0600 GMT) and
1 a.m. (0900 GMT) from the Russian Northern Fleet SSBN Kareliya (Russian
designation Project 667 BDRM, NATO designation 'Delta-IV') in the Barents
Sea. Half an hour later the warheads successfully hit their designated targets
more than 6,000km away at the Kura testing ground off the coast of Kamchatka.[1,2]
According to Russian Navy spokesman Igor Dygalo, both tests were conducted
as part of a program to extend the service life of older weaponry and were
dedicated to the election of Vladimir Putin as president and commander-in-chief
of the Russian armed forces.[1,3] Sources: [1] "Russia Tests Two Ageing Sea-Based
Missiles," Reuters, 27 March 2000. [2] "Raketnaya strelba podvodnoy lodki,"
Nazavisimaya gazeta, online
edition, http://www.ng.ru, 28
March 2000. [3] "Strategicheskaya podvodnaya lodka
SF uspeshno proizvela povtorniy pusk ballisticheckoy rakety," Interfax, 27
March 2000. {Entered 4/5/00 EV}
11/17/99: TWO SLBMS FIRED BY NORTHERN FLEET SSBN On 17 November 1999, a Typhoon-class SSBN of the
Russian Northern Fleet launched two RSM-52 (NATO designation SS-N-20 'Sturgeon')
SLBMs from a submerged position in the Barents Sea.[1,2] The launches were
performed two hours apart. The RSM-52 missiles were chosen for testing as
part of a program to extend the service life of this type of missile. The
warheads hit targets located on the Kamchatka peninsula's Klyuchi testing
ground 30 minutes after the launch.[2] Russian Navy Commander-in-Chief Vladimir
Kuroyedov stated that "the naval strategic forces demonstrated a high
level of combat readiness and met all modern requirements."[1] Russian
telemetry reception stations followed the SLBMs along their flightpath and
the Russian early warning system and C3 system were also tested as part of
the exercise. [2] This test launching coincided with the OSCE summit meeting
in Istanbul, and some observers have suggested that it was partly intended
as a show of force.[3]
Sources: [1] "S rossiyskogo podvodnogo kreysera
proizveden uspeshnyy pusk dvukh ballisticheskikh raket," Interfax, No.
2, 17 November 19999. [2] Valeriy Aleksin, "Nasha strategicheskaya
mosch zhiva," Nezavisimaya gazeta, 19 November 1999, pp.1-2; in
WPS Oborona i Bezopasnost, No. 137, 22 November 1999. [3] Roberto Suro, "Russia's Ailing
Military Flexes Muscles to West; Air, Missile and Sea Exercises Fail to Stir
Alarm," International Herald Tribune, 19 November 1999, p. 7;
in Lexis-Nexis Academic Universe, http://web.lexis-nexis.com.
{Entered 12/1/99 VT} 10/2/99: PACIFIC FLEET DELTA III SSBN CONDUCTS SLBM TEST LAUNCH On 2 October 1999, the Pacific Fleet Delta III SSBN Petropavlovsk-Kamchatka
launched an RSM-50 [NATO designation SS-N-18 'Stingray'] SLBM . The missile
hit the target area located at Cape Kanin Nos in northern Russia near
the Barents Sea.[1] The exercises and test launches that concluded with this
launch were termed an "unprecedented" event in the history of the
Russian strategic forces.[2]
[1] "Rossiyskiy atomnyy podvodnyy raketonosets osushchestvil
uspeshnyy pusk ballisticheskoy rakety iz akvatorii okhotskogo morya,"
Interfax, 2 October 1999. [2] Ilya Kudrov, "Rossiya igrayet strategicheskimi muskulami,"
Nezavisimoye voyennoye obozreniye, No. 39, 8-14 October 1999, p. 1.{Entered
11/30/99 VT}
10/1/99: PACIFIC AND NORTHERN
FLEET SSBNS CONDUCT TEST LAUNCHES On 1 October 1999, the naval strategic nuclear forces
together with the rocket-space defense troops of the Strategic Rocket Forces
held a routine test of combat readiness.[1] A Delta III SSBN of the Pacific
Fleet successfully launched an RSM-50 (NATO designation SS-N-18 'Stingray')
SLBM from a submerged position in the Sea of Okhotsk. The SLBM hit the target,
located on cape Kanin Nos, with a very high degree of accuracy and precisely
at the designated time.[1,2] The rocket-space defense troops' radars followed
the SLBM during its 7,000km flight, transmitting data on its flight to the
SRF's central command and control point.[1] Another Delta III SSBN of the
Northern Fleet fired an RSM-50 (SS-N-18) SLBM from a submerged position in
the Barents Sea.[1,3] According to Interfax, the SLBM was destroyed at a "designated
altitude" as part of a program aimed at extending the service life of
this type of missile.[3] However, according to one report the missile experienced
"technical defects" which necessitated its destruction.[4] On the
same day, a Topol (NATO designation SS-25 Sickle) ICBM was test launched from
the Plesetsk test range.[1] (Please see the ICBM
test launch file for more information.)
Sources: [1] Vladimir Tundarov, "Popast
v kolyshaek," Krasnaya Zvezda, 2 October 1999, p. 2. [2] "Strategicheskiy atomnyy raketonosets
TOF proizvel uspeshnyy pusk ballisticheskoy rakety iz podvodnogo polozheniya,"
Interfax, No. 1, 1 October 1999. [3] "Strategicheskaya podvodnaya
lodka Severnogo Flota proizvela pusk rakety s posleduyuschey samolikvidatsiyey,"
Interfax, No. 2, 1 October 1999. {Entered 11/8/99 VT} [4] Ilya Kudrov, "Rossiya igrayet strategicheskimi muskulami,"
Nezavisimoye voyennoye obozreniye, No. 39, 8-14 October 1999, p. 1.
{Updated 11/29/99 VT} 4/1/99: DELTA III SUCCESSFULLY FIRES SLBM On 1 April 1999, during large-scale exercises of
the Northern Fleet in the Barents Sea, a Delta III SSBN successfully launched
an SLBM from a submerged position.[1,2] The target on Kamchatka was hit precisely
at the designated time.[1] The purpose of the exercise was to test the combat
readiness of the naval strategic nuclear forces.[3]
Sources: [1] "Fleet Exercises: 'Excellent
Firing,'" Krasnaya zvezda, 2 April 1999, p. 3; in "Delta-Class
Sub Successful SLBM Launch," FBIS Document FTS19990408001877. [2] "Vremya" Newscast, Russian
Public Television, 1 April 1999; in "TV Shows Missile Launch from
Submarine," FBIS Document FTS19990408001235. [3] ITAR-TASS, 1 April 1999; in "Russians
Test Ballistic Missile in Barents Sea," FBIS Document FTS19990401000339.
{Entered 10/5/99 VT} 8/21/98: YELTSIN VISITS NORTHERN FLEET, OBSERVES
SLBM LAUNCH Russian President Boris Yeltsin visited the Northern
Fleet and watched naval exercises from aboard the nuclear-powered cruiser
Petr Velikiy on 21 August. The exercises involved 17 surface
ships, including the aircraft carrier Admiral Kuznetsov, and the missile
cruiser Marshal Ustinov.[1] The launch of an RSM-50 (SS-N-18)
SLBM was conducted by a Kalmar class (Delta-III) SSBN. The launch was
reportedly a success, with the missile's warheads reaching their target area
in the Kamchatka peninsula.[1] Ten cruise missiles (of unspecified type)
were also fired during the exercise.[2]
Sources: [1] Sergey Golotyuk and Vladimir
Yermolin, "President's Military Success. Missile Reaches Kamchatka
Under Supreme Commander in Chief's Direction," Russkiy Telegraf,
22 August 1998, p. 2; in "Yeltsin Visits Northern Fleet, Sees Missile
Launch," FBIS-UMA-98-237, 25 August 1998. [2] Interfax,
21 August 1998; in "Nuclear Submarines Guarded Maneuvers Attended by
Yeltsin," FBIS-UMA-98-233, 21 August 1998.{Entered 3/2/99 jl} 2/19/98: TWO SLBMS SUCCESSFULLY LAUNCHED FROM
DELTA-IV SSBN According to ITAR-TASS, a Russian Delta-IV SSBN conducted
test launches of two sea-launched ballistic missiles (SLBM) from the northern
Barents Sea. The test launches were reportedly successful, with the
warheads landing in target areas on the Kamchatka peninsula.
["Russian
Submarine Test Fires 2 Strategic Missiles," ITAR-TASS, 19 February 1998;
in FBIS-UMA-98-050, 19 February 1998.]{Entered 3/2/99 jl}
11/19/97:EXPERIMENTAL
SLBM TEST FAILS, MISSILE DESTROYED A test launch of the experimental RSM-52V SLBM (US
Navy designation SS-NX-28) failed at the Central Naval Weapons Range in Nenoksa
(Arkhangelsk Oblast) on 19 November 1997. The missile exploded shortly
after launch at an altitude of only 200 meters with a force that could
be felt in Severodvinsk, 40km away.[1] Russian Defense Minister Igor
Sergeyev, who was present for the test, told journalists only that the
missile blew up after launch, and announced that a special commission headed
by Navy Commander-in-Chief Vladimir Kuroyedov would investigate the cause
of the failure.[2] It was not clear from media reports whether the missile
exploded spontaneously or was deliberately destroyed as a safety measure after
some of its systems failed. The RSM-52V is being developed by the Makayev
Design Bureau (Chelyabinsk Oblast) on the basis of the solid-fuel RSM-52/R-39
SLBM (NATO designation SS-N-20), which is deployed on Typhoon class
SSBNs. The new missile may be intended to replace the RSM-52/R-39 on
Typhoon class SSBNs, as an upgraded RSM-52/R-39 (termed the R-39UTTKh)
was developed from 1985-1989, and accepted into service by the Soviet Navy
in 1989. This earlier upgraded missile, with more accurate guidance systems,
more energetic solid-fuel propellant, and improvements to the post-boost vehicle,
was clearly intended for retrofitting into Typhoon class SSBNs, although
Western sources believe that significant production was not carried out at
that time. Portions of the RSM-52/R-39 and the improved R-39UTTKh were reportedly
made at the Pavlograd Chemical Plant in Ukraine, which in combination with
financial difficulties may explain why the the new Russian-produced version
of the upgraded missile has been in development so long.[3] Financial considerations
may now prevent retrofitting the new RSM-52V into Typhoon class SSBNs,
however, and it is possible that the new missile is intended for deployment
on Borey class SSBNs, the first of which is under
construction. The older RSM-52 also had significant difficulties
during its development process, with several failed tests. An unnamed
Russian admiral told Interfax on 21 November 1997 that the explosion of the
RSM-52V "is just a failure in the testing of a new defense system,"
arguing that such complex systems must be tested about 20 times. He said the
failed test was only the fourth test of the new SLBM, adding that the RSM-52V
had entered testing only in late 1996. Alluding to the fact that solid-fuel
SLBMs were previously manufactured in Ukraine, the admiral said the Russian
designers of the new missile were facing "somewhat new" challenges,
and expressed confidence that the Makayev Design Bureau would resolve the
problems by 2000. [4]
Sources: [1] Yevgeniy Federov and Aleksandr Raskin,
"Nuclear Missile Explodes over Arkhangelsk. That Was an Exercise,"
Kommersant-daily, 21 November 1997, p. 1; in "Explosion Calls
Adoption of RSM-52V Missile into Question," FBIS-SOV-97-325. [2] Interfax, 20 November 1997; in "Russian
Ballistic Missile Explodes at Arkhangelsk Launch," FBIS-SOV-97-324. [3] Steven J. Zaloga, "The Thunder
Inside Russia's 'Typhoons'," Jane's Intelligence Review, December
1996, p. 536. [4] Interfax,
21 November 1997; in "Russian Admiral Plays Down Failure of Missile Test,"
{entered 2/12/98 sdp}
7/23/97: PACIFIC FLEET SSBN LAUNCHES SLBM On 23 July 1997, a Pacific Fleet SSBN successully
conducted a scheduled launch of an SLBM targeted at one of the Nothern Fleet's
test areas.[1] During the same exercises, two Pacific Fleet submarines, the
Omsk and the Chelyabinsk, simultaneously fired two "Granit"
ship-to-ship missiles for the first time.[2,3]
Sources: [1] Leonid Vinogradov, ITAR-TASS, 23
July 1997; in "Russian Pacific Fleet Submarine Tests Ballistic Missile,"
FBIS-UMA-97-204, 23 July 1997. [2] Interfax, 23 July 1997; in "Pacific
Fleet Submarines Test Fire Cruise Missiles," FBIS-UMA-97-204, 23 July
1997. [3] "Segodnya utrom"
newscast, 24 July 1997; in "Independent Russian TV Shows Submarine Missile
Firing," FBIS-SOV-97-205. {Entered 10/6/99 VT} 1/15/97: SS-N-18 SLBM TEST LAUNCH In the first SLBM test launch of 1997, a Russian Delta-III SSBN of the
Northern Fleet successfully launched an RSM-50 (SS-N-18) SLBM from the Barents
Sea to a target off the Kamchatka peninsula. [Interfax, 1/15/97, in "Arctic Submarine Successfully Tests
Ballistic Missile," FBIS-SOV-97-011.] {Entered 1/17/97 JL}
10/3/96: SLBM TEST LAUNCH BY NORTHERN FLEET An SLBM of an unspecified type was successfully launched by an SSBN of
the Northern Fleet as part of the Redut-96 strategic exercise. (See
10/3/96 entry under C3I for more information on Redut-96.) ["'Prezidentskaya knopka' srabotala," Krasnaya zvezda,
10/4/96, p. 1; "Strategicheskaya komandno-shtabnaya trenirovka,"
Krasnaya zvezda, 10/3/96, p. 1] {Entered JL 11/17/96}
7/15/96: TWO SSBNS CONDUCT TEST LAUNCHES Two SSBNs of the Northern Fleet successfully conducted test launches of
ballistic missiles during exercises in the Barents Sea. Two types of SLBMs
were launched: one SS-N-8 (RSM-40) and one SS-N-23 (RSM-54). The SLBMs tested
were reportedly drawn from long-term storage, apparently in order to test
the condition of the aging missile force. The exercises also involved coordination
with other strategic nuclear forces and the Russian ballistic early warning
missile system (BMEWS). Northern fleet officials stated that all the missiles
accurately hit their targets. [Press-Tsentr VMF RF, "Podvodnyy 'strategi' strelyali uspeshno,"
Krasnaya zvezda, 7/17/96, p. 1; Vasiliy Belousov, "Atomic Submarines
Practice Firing in Barents Sea," ITAR-TASS, 7/15/96; FBIS-SOV-96-137,
7/15/96.] {Entered 8/15/96 KD Revised 8/29/96 JL}
6/28/96: PACIFIC FLEET CONDUCTS TRIPLE TEST LAUNCH For the first time, the Pacific Fleet launched ballistic missiles simultaneously
from three submarines. The successful launch was part of a command-staff exercise
run by Commander Admiral Vladimir Kuroyedov intended to test the combat readiness
of the Russian Navy's nuclear deterrence forces. A Navy official announced
that in the year 2002 the Navy would start receiving a new generation of SSBN
submarines. ["Ballisticheskiy zall Tikhookeanskogo flota," Krasnaya
zvezda, 7/2/96, p. 1. Doug Clarke, "Fleet Practices Multiple Missile
Launches," OMRI DAILY DIGEST Vol. 2, No. 128, 7/02/96; O. Zhurman, "Vesti"
newscast, Moscow Russian Television Network, 7/10/96; "Pacific Fleet
Submarine Missile Exercises End Successfully," FBIS-UMA-96-138-S, 7/10/96;
Interfax, 7/2/96] {Revised 9/14/96 KVY}
3/26/96:NORTHERN FLEET HOLDS LARGEST EXERCISES SINCE SOVIET
COLLAPSE Izvestiya reported that in March 1996 the
Northern Fleet held naval exercises on a scale larger than any since the collapse
of the Soviet Union. The exercises reportedly involved 32 surface combatants,
including the new aircraft carrier Admiral Kuznetsov, and 22 submarines, including
SSBNs. Air support for the exercises included 49 sorties with coordination
and control provided by A-50 Airborne Warning and Control System (AWACS) aircraft.
As Izvestiya noted, the show of naval strength was held in the Barents Sea
and Norwegian Sea just before President Yeltsin was to visit Norway (to discuss
issues including demarcation of the continental shelf in the region), and
just after a NATO military exercise in the region. [Viktor Litovkin, "Severnyy flot pokazal svoyu moshch' pered
vizitom B. Yeltsina v Norvegiyu," Izvestiya, 3/26/96, p. 2.]