Improving relations between countries making friends out of enemies
can reduce the risk of war. This, ultimately, is the best way to reduce the
risk of WMD use, particularly in the following global relationships:
United States and Russia No Longer Enemies
The end of the Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union reduced
tensions between the two countries. This, in turn, led to a reduction in the
threat of WMD use. Tensions were eased between the two countries principally
because of changes within the Soviet Union. It ended its expansionist ideological
competition with the United States and its anti-democratic domestic political
system. The subsequent emergence of a democratic Russia and 14 other newly
independent states that were once part of the Soviet empire reduced the risk
of war between the two major nuclear powers even further. Most recently, the
United States and Russia signed the
Treaty of Moscow to reduce their deployed strategic nuclear warheads from
about 6,000 each to between 1,700-2,200 over the next ten years. Many questions remain,
however.
- Can the United States and Russia reduce
their nuclear forces to non-threatening levels?
- Can the two countries reduce the risks of accidental or unauthorized
nuclear launches?
- Can the United States and Russia work together towards transparency and
confidence-building measures as the U.S. pursues its ballistic missile
defense program?
- How will Russia's new alliance with China affect U.S. dominance in global
economic and military affairs?
South Africa at Peace
The end of the Cold War led to accommodation between South Africa and its neighbors,
which had close ties to the Soviet Union. This, and political change within
South Africa that brought replacement of its right-wing, white-supremacist
government with democratically elected leaders, led the country to eliminate
its nuclear and biological weapons.
North Korea: New Concerns
Political dialogue and a growing easing of tensions between North Korea and
the United States led to understandings
through which North Korea has frozen its nuclear weapons program and suspended
tests of ballistic missiles. South
Korea has played a major role in reducing tensions in this area with its "sunshine
policy" of seeking better ties with the North. In September
2002, the leaders of Japan and North Korea issued the
Pyongyang Declaration. Both sides agreed to cooperate in several
fields to reduce tensions, including working together to resolve nuclear issues
on the Korean Peninsula. They also agreed to open negotiations aimed at
normalizing diplomatic relations.
Questions remain, however, as to whether North Korea is ready to give up its
nuclear arms and long-range missiles. Some analysts have also criticized the
United States for rewarding North Korea with economic benefits after it violated
the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).
Doubts about the success of these efforts have particularly been highlighted by
the October 2002 North Korean confirmation of its
secret uranium enrichment program. Although North Korea announced in
September 2002 that it would
extend its ballistic missile testing moratorium beyond 2003, it has since
threatened to reverse its decision. North Korea has also argued that it
has the right to possess nuclear weapons in order to protect its national
security, and has stated that the 1994
Agreed Framework was effectively
nullified. Concerns over the fate of the Agreed Framework intensified
in December 2002, when North Korea announced it would
reactivate the nuclear reactor at Yongbyon, which had been closed under the
1994 agreement. Days later, North Korea called on the International Atomic
Energy Agency to
remove monitoring equipment from all nuclear facilities, and to allow North
Korea access to materials that had been sealed by the IAEA after the 1994
agreement. Subsequently, the DPRK disrupted most of the safeguards
equipment at the Yongbyon facilities. Later, all
IAEA inspectors were expelled from the country. The IAEA has responded by
giving North Korea
one more chance to comply before referring the matter to the UN Security
Council, while it deplored North Korea's unilateral actions in the strongest
terms.
The United States, Japan, South Korea, and other countries are working to
resolve their concerns with North Korea via diplomatic and economic channels.
North Korea has proposed that "security concerns" be addressed through dialogue
and a non-aggression treaty with the United States. The status of the
agreement
remains under discussion. In January 2003, the United States signaled
that it is
willing to hold talks with North Korea, but insisted that it will not offer
any concessions to North Korea before existing commitments are met.
Despite these diplomatic overtures, North Korea announced its
immediate withdrawal from the NPT on January 10, 2003. Pyongyang cited U.S.
hostility as the reason for the withdrawal from the treaty and denounced the
IAEA as an "American stooge", but stated that it currently had no intention to
develop nuclear weapons. The United States, South Korea, Japan and other
neighboring states regarded the announcement as a setback for nonproliferation
and peace on the Korean Peninsula, but continued diplomatic efforts to resolve
the situation.
Peace in the Middle East?
Successful implementation of the Middle East Peace Process would reduce the
risk of WMD use by Israel and its neighbors. It would also improve prospects
for the implementation of WMD control measures in the region. Similarly, the
advent of more moderate
leaders in Iran and Iraq could reduce WMD threats in the Persian Gulf region.
Whether these developments will occur is difficult to predict. There are strong
differences of opinion among political leaders and experts on these questions.
Reduced Risk of War Between India and Pakistan?
Improved relations between India and Pakistan could reduce the risk of nuclear
war in South Asia. This would be the case especially if there were an agreement
over the future of the disputed region of Kashmir. Recently, however, tensions
between these two nuclear armed states have risen because of new attacks in
India by terrorist groups based in Pakistani-controlled Kashmir. |