Risky Business

Trump, Xi, and Putin’s nuclear moment — handle with care

Presidents Trump, Xi, and Putin are scheduled to hold a trilateral meeting on November 19 on the sidelines of the APEC Summit in Shenzhen. According to Trump the agenda will include “denuclearization.”

Why it matters: While it is not clear what the president means by “denuclearization,” the meeting comes at an important moment when the guardrails that have helped manage and reduce nuclear risks for decades have been seriously weakened.

Russia’s war in Ukraine, China’s expanding nuclear forces, growing tensions among nuclear-armed powers, uncertainty surrounding alliance commitments, and the rapid evolution of emerging technologies are increasing risks and straining strategic stability.

Yet efforts to manage these risks have not kept pace. U.S.-Russian arms control agreements have lapsed, strategic dialogue has stalled, and few channels exist to address emerging risks from interactions between nuclear, conventional, cyber, space, and AI domains.

State of play: Strategic competition increasingly spans all of these domains. Actions in one can have unintended consequences in another, creating new pathways for miscalculation and nuclear escalation.

Meanwhile, the United States, Russia, and China are each increasing their reliance on nuclear weapons, making effective dialogue and risk reduction more urgent.

  • China is expanding and modernizing its nuclear forces, while rejecting calls to join trilateral arms control talks, arguing that its nuclear arsenal is significantly smaller than those of the United States and Russia.
  • Russia is calling for renewed strategic stability discussions as it continues to employ nuclear rhetoric in the context of the war in Ukraine and has conditioned further nuclear risk reduction progress on a change in U.S. support for Ukraine.
  • And, the United States is moving ahead with an overhaul of its entire nuclear weapons arsenal, command and control systems, and delivery platforms

Moment of opportunity: The deteriorating security environment makes sustained engagement among leaders more important, not less.

Rebuilding nuclear guardrails will take time, political will, and skilled diplomacy. Direct engagement is the only way to establish common understandings, identify shared interests, and make progress on practical risk reduction measures.

If Shenzhen can kick-start meaningful U.S.-Russia and U.S.-China discussions on strategic stability and nuclear risk reduction, it will be an important step forward.

What’s next: Success should be measured not by whether the leaders agree on a grand bargain but whether the meeting delivers tangible next steps to strengthen nuclear guardrails.

Productive outcomes could include:

  • Commitments by all three countries to maintain meaningful human control over nuclear-use decisions and agreed channels to engage at a senior level on AI-nuclear risk.
  • Commitment to conduct unliteral, periodic, comprehensive “fail-safe” reviews to manage and mitigate AI-nuclear risk to nuclear weapons and their component systems.
  • Agreement between the United States and China to establish enhanced crisis communication channels at the political and military levels.
  • Initiation of talks to establish a reciprocal agreement between the United States and China to provide advance notification of test launches of ballistic missiles (this would complement existing U.S.-Russian and Russian-Chinese agreements).
  • Shared commitment to U.S.-Russian and U.S.-Chinese dialogues on strategic stability, including evolving risks from cyber, space, AI, and nuclear weapons.

Bottom line: Keep expectations modest.

Progress on nuclear risk reduction requires sustained engagement and dialogue among diplomatic, political, and military experts from all parties on a range of shared security concerns.

If Shenzhen produces a commitment by leaders and clear directives to initiate such dialogues that would be a significant outcome.

Stay Informed

Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest on nuclear and biological threats.

Sign Up


New START Has Expired. Congress’s Oversight Tools Shouldn’t.

Risky Business

New START Has Expired. Congress’s Oversight Tools Shouldn’t.

Congress’s oversight of U.S. nuclear policy is at a critical juncture. When the U.S. Senate approved New START in 2010, it mandated several annual reports and certifications to ensure strong congressional oversight of Russian compliance with the treaty. These requirements expired along with the treaty, creating oversight gaps just as strategic competition heats up.



See All

Close

My Resources

Subscribe to NTI

Sign up for regular updates on innovative, real-world solutions to existential threats.

Get Updates